If you love Catan...
I play this a lot bc I love Catan, but this app really is not that well made. Its not so bad that I dont play however... But mostly I play offline.
The pros:
-pretty easy to figure out the features
-AI players are pretty good, pretty realistic, but could use some more that are more willing to trade
Cons:
-online needs timers. I actually take a little while when first starting, bc thats where I think much of the game is decided. Maybe 1/2 my games someone leaves during this time bc their too impatient. The timer should be one for setup play (1st 2 turns) and a separate timer for other play. That way when people are joining a game they know what to expect
-screens need to have a button to allow a view of the board (which they DO have for the robber?!?)
-if offered a trade you should be able to counter with the option of falling back to the original offer.
-in online mode, if people drop the board should stay up and whomever created the table should have the option to allow someone to take their place: just like the hugely popular yahoo online games.
lcoreyl about
Catan Classic, v4.6.1